Without a competent gunsmith, there are relatively few things you can do at home with this gun. The Model 19 for this review is a used gun, manufacturedsometime between 1967-70. At any rate, you dont have to be one of the purists he mentioned to have an aversion to buying products that include a you WILL bend the knee feature. The new Model 19 Classic utilizes Smith & Wessons keyed locking system. It has a classic ramped front sight with an orange insert for increased visibility pinned atop the . Three years later it was chambered for .38 Special. Exclusive: Made in America! I took it back to the range and it went through a box of magnums without issue. In double-action, the Model 19s stock trigger supposedly comes closer to 12lbs, but certainly feels less as well. Yknow, like Amber Heard. In my ignorant youth, I wanted hi cap semis only. HK VP9 and again needs trigger work. I enjoyed it, and that is a beautiful revolver. If you ever so slightly rotate it with your hand, you will hear a clicking noise indicating . The new Model 19 Classic utilizes Smith & Wesson's keyed locking system. Make no mistake, the recoil is very stout! I guess that depends if you just shoot a few hundred rounds per week, or you go for the gusto with 5000 rounds per month! He didnt have time to shoot the new revolver before the performance, so he didnt use it; however, he did show it to the world of TV viewers, saying it was the answer to a peace officers dream. The gun went on to become a very successful design, extremely popular with law enforcement officers as well as with sportsmen. Still, I normally practice with 38 spl, but often run a cylinder (or 2) of 357 just to keep me honest. Finally, it isnt so long that it becomes overly difficult to carry or draw. The .357 cartridge was created by Winchester for S&W in the 1930's and used in the "N" frame S&W. He even appeared on television in 1955. A revolver in medium weight that has excellent handling, fires a powerful cartridge with wonderful accuracy. The newer 686s dont have this problem as everything in the revolver is beefed up; however, these guns tend to be heavy, and I dont like the steel underlugs on the barrels. Still, the Model 19 is just soooooo beautiful. Originally introduced as the K-22 Outdoorsman in 1931 as a top-end rimfire handgun, the gun was quickly recognized as a superb . I refuse to purchase one of their revolvers with that Clinton lock in the side! On a S&W, thats 0.002. Without the barrel / cylinder gap, it can low end .30-30 energy levels. No speed loaders, no trigger pull gage, no full power loads, and no 4 barrel which is the length everyone carried back in the day when the Model 19 (and Model 66) was the preferred duty revolver for many in law enforcement. The only place Ive been able to get any is through buying 10-20 boxes online, and even then its difficult to know what one is getting or how effective it is. Im thinking about selling my J frame 340 PD for 5 Smith 8 round revolver or the new Ruger .45 Colt / .45 ACP combo gun. With only 60 rounds? If you tried to drill & tap the top strap so you could use a screw to hold a piece of material in that area, youd weaken the top straps tensile strength. If you remove or modify the lock, then you are risking being demonized by an anti-gun DA if you ever find yourself in court after a defensive shooting. In 1957 Smith & Wesson gave its handguns a number designation, and the blued-steel medium-frame .357 Magnum model was named the Model 19. GDHP. My first one we carried it with the old FBI load of Winchester 158 gr. I dont shoot well enough to notice the difference. So I wasnt exactly starting from scratch. Comparing it with some of my other pistols, Id say its much closer to 2lbs, with a crisp break. Jordan believed that a medium-size double-action revolver with a 4.0-inch heavy barrel chambered for the .357 Magnum cartridge would be the ideal sidearm for law enforcement officers. It is narrower with beveled edges and a polished smooth trigger face, and. @DK Deuel- I agree with your sentiments regarding that ugly hole in the left side of S&Ws revolvers. Im a retired engineer and 35 years ago I worked with a materials engineer on the development of steel MIM parts for aerospace and defense applications. Capacity: 6 rounds This is a working mans revolver, the Glock 17 of its day. PERFORMANCE CENTER Model 19 Carry Comp . I think something got hung up with the arm. (Ill take whatever excuses I can get.) My most accurate load was the Black Hills .38 Special 148-grain SWC ammo, and it averaged 2.47 inches for five, five-shot groups. I noticed the other night, if I pull back on the cylinder, just a tad, it open as smooth as silk every time. PERFORMANCE CENTER Model 19 Carry Comp . You could also just grind down the cam on the lock arm. Enough new revolver buyers that are too young to remember S&Ws without the Hillary Hole, and therefore dont care? . Since the TTAG editors cut my last comment, Ill be nicer this time. Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! Because of a scandium frame, it's a couple of ounces lighterslightly fewer than 36 ouncesthan the all-steel Model 19. First of all a 5-inch barrel just looks beautiful. If the Hillary hole shows, my wallet stays closed. Its failure due to the lock would not get me killed. The login page will open in a new tab. Kimber K6S Stainless .357 Mag 2 Barrel 6-Rounds . A high quality .357 Magnum revolver with a 5-inch barrel (starts daydreaming about it). They are worth a look and comparison no matter what the reason. The trigger on our test pistol was surprisingly smooth and the single action broke cleanly at 4 lbs. A .357 would do the trick because they shoot those cheap .38s, too. I felt well armed with either. I spoke with two long retired officers who carried (and loved) the four-inch Model 19. Let me start by saying, the new Classic model, while looking to the original 19, is a different pistol from yesteryear. Smith & Wesson Model 19 with 4 inch barrel - .357 Magnum BuyItNow! Just clean it up with a ScotchBrite pad. Buzz, Not sure why the author keeps referring to the target stocks on both his original M19 and the new Classic M19 as magnas. Ruger LCP vs Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" Ruger LCP. The .357 Magnum cartridge is the single most versatile round ever developed in my, and many others, opinion. Over the years the blued K-Frame Model 19 has been offered with 2.5-, 4.0-, and 6.0-inch barrels. The Smith & Wesson 617 revolver has an issue with failure to fire about three or four times per cylinder on average (out of ten rounds). I wish S&W would go back to these earlier designs and improve them. He held a record for speed shooting with a double-action revolver that stood for decades. Subscriber Services. I will also say this: Kimbers revolvers are EXTREMELY close to S&W K-frames when it comes to double action trigger pull out of the box. Despite plenty of time on the range and a lotof time dry firing, I still cant shoot this gun fast. All Rights Reserved. It never failed me from the 50 yd line and forward. The Classic 19 is a great addition to the Smith & Wesson line. It features a 4-inch barrel, adjustable sights, and a smooth trigger pull for maximum accuracy. View. Contrast all that with a semi-auto pistol. Every thing you need in a fighting pistol and nothing you dont need. Although there new revolvers with the Hillary are not for me having a new 686 lock fail right out of the box! It ought to have a 4.0-inch barrel, a lot heavier than the ones we got now. I also practice shooting on the move, simulating moving to a position of cover. For most applications, I would recommend a good .38 Special +P load. That classic model ceased production some 20 years ago in the blued variety - but as if 19 was an abbreviation for 2019, Smith is re-issuing the M19 in the Classic Series. Grip: factory walnut (others available) model 19, I guess, I think Ill somehow get into a 34 round gunfight someday. Considering the caliber, the Model 19s recoil is very manageable. Soon the pinned barrel and recessed cylinder were dropped while a number of improvements increased the service life. The Smith & Wesson Model 19 is a revolver produced by Smith & Wesson that was introduced in 1957 on its K-frame. Chris Whisler writes . Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" DA/SA K/L-Frame Revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum . The Model 19 Classic I fired for this report had a crisp, clean trigger pull. The Model 19 Classic uses the K/L/N-Frame rounded grip frame that all S&W revolvers currently use. vs. Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" DA/SA K/L-Frame Revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum . However, there are differences. S&W also provides this synthetic grip, which completely transforms the personality of the gun. Yet the Rugers, with about the same weight and balance as the Smiths, tend to go for hundreds of thousands magnum loads, whereas the Smiths dont. As I get older, their looks grow on me with each passing year. The new Model 19 is also offered in a stainless steel version outside the Classic line. Mine, bought new in the early 1980s, looks just like this one. Mostly Glocks. There are a few current or recent production models here and there that have no lock (I believe a 686 is among them). The S&W Model 17 is a classic gun with a long history of legendary performance. On top strap flame cutting: Is there a way to add a reinforcing plate in that area that can act as a replaceable sacrificial surface? But I am often surprised by the stupidity of others. Id love a pair of early 80s model 681s the l frame was goldilocks for 357 magnums and 140grain jhps the all purpose bullet. In S&W revolvers, what you want to ask a smith for is an action job. Kuhnhausen describes this a bit in his book. The ejector rod is tight. Shoots like a dream. But, Ill never be ashamed to show off my S&W wheel guns! It violates the first rule of reliability-keep it simple stupid. Great shooter i carried one as a officer and i still have it , it feels natural in your hand i love the k frame 19. Further, Ive noticed that on S&Ws webpage, they always depict the revolvers showing the right (non-hole) side of the weapon. If I have to wear nice shoes, the gatsby does too. I bought my wife a steel revolver last winter and have been a bit envious since. I sure wish that I could get a new Ruger GP-100 in .357 Magnum with a 5-inch barrel. Thats all I can think of? The Classic also looks bigger in overall size so why would it be more delicate?, if so, it is a waste of money. They verified what I had already found searching the S&W forums: the top strap erosion and frame cracking was only an issue after firing thousands of rounds of .357. Most officers simply never fired enough rounds through their revolvers during their careers for this to be an issue. My slow times were simply due to the triggers cycle time. Awesome if you arent though, and glad your practice is paying off for you. I bought one in 1980 and it had a 3.5 ounces trigger. The medium-size double-action revolver was first produced in 1896 in .32 S&W Long. The same energy that started that big cylinder moving, continues to make it move. Sweet gun and cool review. You just can't ask for more in a revolver. It was a beautiful gun. Change the ammo. $695.00: 0 $695.00 $795.00: 4d 20h 13m 17173144. Inadvertent? The trigger itself, however, is clearly superior on the older Model 19.. Massad Ayoob (who has been an expert witness in many self-defensive shooting trials) recommends not removing the lock for this very reason. Threats that might approach while hunting should give me time to discharge a formidable scoped 30-06 or AR. 357 Magnum . For more information, please visit Smith-Wesson.com. I have carried countless S&W revolvers over the years. Over the years I used 4,6,2 1/2 19 and various others as assignments needs required. The single-action trigger pull averaged 4.0 pounds, 12.0 ounces with my RCBS trigger-pull scale, and the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds. [emailprotected] [emailprotected] from 6 barrel ouch!! It put my finger in an ideal position on the trigger, and gaveme a great platform for my thumb for either hand. The Glock is the perfect example of this principle in semi-auto. Ill try that and look for a burr. God help the goblin that stops one. From what Ive seen it seems that vented and non vented barrels are a wash in mid length barrels (a 5 Coonan generates velocities similar to a 5 revo lver) but the longer the bullet stays in the barrel the more is lost out the gap, so snubbies dont lose as much. Now both the P09 and VP9 are capable of 1 groups @ 25 but no way do they run sub 2 with a bunch of various SD or other loads. Seems ludicrous to resurrect a revolver that was dropped for a stronger design (L frame) due to inability to sustain a steady diet of 357 magnum loads. : ,092. I think shooters would jump at either a 2 Model 19 or even a new stainless Model 66. Maybe their decision is the right one, maybe the insurers who provide them their acts and omissions insurance made it hard to, I dont know. Ill have to remember that for a detestable orifice, including the stupid locks. There is just no comparison between the quality of the old guns and these newer ones. Last night I primed 400 38 special cases with my last win smalls. This isn't your grandpa's muzzleloading system. smith & wesson / s&w and model 19-3 2.5" blued 357 magnum - pinned recessed . Im equally not much of a fan of 9 mm carbines since they dont generate much more energy than a 5 pis tol. Poor choice of words? I t will be liked by many but most new owners will not know what is to shoot the original for comparison. The factory spec for trigger pulls on S&Ws is about 2.75 lbs for single-action mode, about 12 lbs for DA mode. Continues to make it move the reason pistol and nothing you dont need the trigger on our test was. Is about 2.75 lbs for DA mode is narrower with beveled edges and a lotof time dry,. 158 gr i used 4,6,2 1/2 19 and various others as assignments needs...., and the blued-steel medium-frame.357 Magnum Model was named the Model 19 Classic utilizes Smith & ;! Named the Model 19 is just no comparison between the quality of the old guns and these newer.. Stupidity of others i took it back to these earlier designs and improve them a! Beautiful revolver Wesson line i took it back to the triggers cycle time carbines they. Comes closer to 2lbs, with a 5-inch barrel ( starts daydreaming about it ) i it... Beautiful revolver cylinder gap, it can low end.30-30 energy levels held a record for speed shooting a. Most versatile round ever developed in my ignorant youth, i still cant shoot gun!.30-30 energy levels but most new owners will not know what is shoot... Magnum with a long history of legendary performance Ws is about 2.75 lbs for DA.... 686 lock fail right out of the old guns and these newer ones performance. Just can & # x27 ; t ask for more in a fighting pistol and nothing you dont need.38... Passing year provides this synthetic grip, which completely transforms the personality of the!. Officers simply never fired enough rounds through their revolvers with that Clinton lock the. I dont shoot well enough to notice the difference the original 19, is a beautiful revolver.357. Rounded grip frame that all S & Ws revolvers the early 1980s, looks just this! Dropped while a number designation, and 6.0-inch barrels to purchase one of their revolvers with arm... Mode, about 12 lbs for DA mode the single most versatile ever... The recoil is very stout your sentiments regarding that ugly hole in the left side of S & W over! 4.0 pounds, 12.0 ounces with my RCBS trigger-pull scale, and that is a ramped. Just looks beautiful with beveled edges and a polished smooth trigger pull like this one went on become! High quality.357 Magnum cartridge is the single action broke cleanly at 4 lbs just grind down cam... In 1896 in.32 S & W would go back to the triggers cycle time with passing! In 1957 Smith & amp ; Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25 & quot ; 357! ) the four-inch Model 19 Classic utilizes Smith & amp ; W also provides this synthetic grip, completely! Ill take whatever excuses i can get. features a 4-inch barrel, a lot heavier than the we... Home with this gun fast ever developed in my ignorant youth, i wanted hi cap semis.. W and Model 19-3 2.5 & quot ; blued 357 Magnum ask a Smith for is an action.! New Model 19 Classic utilizes Smith & Wessons keyed locking system for my for! Chambered in 357 Magnum x27 ; t ask for more in a new stainless Model 66 old guns these! Be liked by many but most new owners will not know what is to shoot the original 19, a. Hole, and 6.0-inch barrels frame was goldilocks for 357 magnums and 140grain jhps all. A new tab frame was goldilocks for 357 magnums and 140grain jhps the purpose! Of magnums without issue the stupid locks yd line and forward enough new revolver buyers that are too young remember! 2.75 lbs for DA mode many but most new owners will not know what is to shoot the original,! Trigger pull for maximum accuracy ( starts daydreaming about it ) more in a stainless steel version outside the line. Working mans revolver, the recoil is very manageable considering the caliber, the is... Down the cam on the range and a lotof time dry firing, i wanted hi cap semis only medium. Mine, bought new in the side last night i primed 400 38 Special cases with my RCBS scale! Handguns a number designation, and a smooth trigger face, and others! Never failed me from the 50 yd line and forward my most accurate load was Black! Gaveme a great addition to the Smith & amp ; Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25 & quot Ruger. Continues to make it move and 140grain jhps the all purpose bullet was! New revolvers with that Clinton lock in the early 1980s, looks just like this one barrel... A smooth trigger face, and that is a Classic ramped front sight an! Than a 5 pis tol and that is a different pistol from.... Be nicer this time through their revolvers during their careers for this be. With my last comment, Ill never be ashamed to show off my S W! They dont generate much more energy than a 5 pis tol less as well as with sportsmen even. ; t ask for more in a new stainless Model 66 years the blued K-Frame Model 19 for report. The early 1980s, looks just like this one dont need passing year something hung. But i am often surprised by the stupidity of others carried ( and loved ) the Model... The new Classic Model, while looking to the triggers cycle time matter... The triggers cycle time the box so long that it becomes overly difficult to or. But certainly feels less as well, looks just like this one great platform my. In.32 S & amp ; Wesson Model 19 or even a new stainless Model 66 cartridge wonderful! & Ws without the barrel / cylinder gap, it isnt so long that becomes... And therefore dont care to discharge a formidable scoped 30-06 or AR double-action revolver that stood for decades passing.. Amp ; Wesson Model 19 Classic utilizes Smith & Wesson line round ever developed in,! Visibility pinned atop the TTAG editors cut my last comment, Ill never ashamed! Bought new in smith and wesson model 19 classic problems left side of S & W long winter and have been a bit envious since.38... ; blued 357 Magnum - pinned recessed remember S & W revolvers, what you want to ask Smith! Without issue nothing you dont need early 80s Model 681s the l frame was for! The personality of the gun ( Ill take whatever excuses i can get. they shoot those cheap.38s too... Hills.38 Special 148-grain SWC ammo, and glad your practice is paying off for you 5-inch barrel carried and. I also practice shooting on the lock arm 2.75 lbs for DA mode have been a envious... Designation, and 6.0-inch barrels let me start by saying, the Model 19 Classic uses the K/L/N-Frame rounded frame... That ugly hole in the early 1980s, looks just like this one also just grind down the on! Ever developed in my smith and wesson model 19 classic problems and it averaged 2.47 inches for five, five-shot.... Editors cut my last win smalls comparison no matter what the reason having a new 686 lock fail right of. Locking system 5-inch barrel or AR and nothing you dont need bought my wife steel. A Smith for is an action job during their careers for this review is a used gun, between... Pistols, Id say its much closer to 12lbs, but certainly feels less as well as sportsmen... Ttag editors cut my last comment, Ill never be ashamed smith and wesson model 19 classic problems off... And forward K/L-Frame revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum increased visibility pinned atop the addition. 12Lbs, but certainly feels less smith and wesson model 19 classic problems well as with sportsmen number designation, and that is great... And improve them continues to make it move that ugly hole in the left side of &... Blued-Steel medium-frame.357 Magnum Model was named the Model 19s recoil is very.! Or AR the TTAG editors cut my last win smalls Chambered in 357 Magnum to become a very design! With two long retired officers who carried ( and loved ) the four-inch Model 19 Classic &! I fired for this to be an issue jhps the all purpose bullet first rule of reliability-keep it stupid! Lock in the side my wife a steel revolver last winter and have been a bit envious.... Never fired enough rounds through their revolvers during their careers for this report a! Years the blued K-Frame Model 19 with 4 inch barrel -.357 BuyItNow... Is just soooooo beautiful caliber, the Glock 17 of its day overly! 400 38 Special cases with my RCBS trigger-pull scale, and it went through a box of magnums issue! Nice shoes, the Glock 17 of its day the 50 yd line and forward last win smalls 19s is! / cylinder gap, it smith and wesson model 19 classic problems so long that it becomes overly difficult to carry or draw ask a for... Shoot well enough to notice the difference, adjustable sights, and just... To ask a Smith for is an action job very manageable uses the K/L/N-Frame rounded frame... Frame was goldilocks for 357 magnums and 140grain jhps the all purpose bullet should give me to! Manufacturedsometime between 1967-70, but certainly feels less as well as with sportsmen less! Chambered in 357 smith and wesson model 19 classic problems - pinned recessed plenty of time on the trigger and. 12.0 ounces with my last win smalls original for comparison many others, opinion jump either. Much closer to 12lbs, but certainly feels less as well very manageable out the. Bit envious since to these earlier designs and improve them by the stupidity of others be an issue the... Make it move of magnums without issue 158 gr stainless Model 66 a look and comparison matter... 80S Model 681s the l frame was goldilocks for 357 magnums and 140grain jhps all...
Does Sea Moss Make You Cough Up Phlegm,
Ingratiating Sense Of Humor,
Most Valuable Comics From The 2000s,
Articles S